20 Festive co*cktails That Start With a Carton of Eggnog (2024)

Whether you're looking for a traditional Christmas punch or a fun seasonal twist, this list has so many creative ways to enjoy drinking eggnog. For instance, some of these eggnog co*cktails incorporate other classic holiday flavors like peppermint, gingerbread, and even hot chocolate. Looking for a Christmas tradition from around the world? Try the rompope co*cktail from Mexico or a Puerto Rican coquito for another version of a creamy holiday drink. We've even included a Christmas mocktail if you prefer to skip the spiked part!

And if you love eggnog as much as us, you'll definitely want to check out our list of other fun ways to use eggnog, including an eggnog cake that's sure to impress your house guests. Imagine all the things you can sip and savor while decorating the tree. It will be a happy holiday, indeed!

This method for making eggnog is very similar to making the custard base for homemade ice cream. Just add rum, brandy, half-and-half, and vanilla. Instead of finishing the drink with raw egg whites, this version uses whipped heavy cream!

Get the Homemade Eggnog recipe.

SHOP GLASSES

This may be an easy co*cktail, but that doesn't mean that it's not impressive. Mix Kalua and vodka and then pour in some eggnog and watch the creaminess come to life!

Get the Eggnog White Russian recipe at Snacks and Sips.

Take classic eggnog and add chocolate not once but three times to get this decadent treat. It has melted chocolate and cocoa powder in the drink and chocolate shavings on top for good measure.

Get the Chocolate Eggnog recipe at Creative Culinary.

The great thing about this drink is that everyone can have it! It has no dairy or alcohol so those with dietary restrictions or even kids can have a sip. Want it spiked? Simply add your favorite spirit.

Get the Vegan Caramel Eggnog Mocktail recipe at Orchids and Sweet Tea.

Making eggnog from scratch can take some time, but it doesn't have to. This simple recipe is assembled in the blender and takes a fraction of the time, so you're much closer to co*cktail time then ever before!

Get the Five-Minute Homemade Blender Eggnog recipe at The Chunky Chef.

SHOP BLENDERS

The warm, sweet flavor of maple syrup works so well with the creaminess of eggnog. Top it off with a sprinkle of nutmeg and cinnamon for a perfectly seasonal treat!

Get the Eggnog Maple Martini recipe at 3 Yummy Tummies.

Bourbon lovers will appreciate this fun twist! The bourbon adds even more caramelized, butterscotch flavor to the drink.

Get the Bourbon Eggnog recipe at Britney Breaks Bread.

Coffee liqueur and homemade cinnamon syrup give this co*cktail a ton of seasonal flavor. You can use store-bought eggnog to make the drink even quicker!

Get the Cinnamon-Spiced Eggnog White Russian recipe at A Farmgirl's Dabbles.

Rompope is an eggnog-like drink that hails from Mexico. The biggest difference you'll see in this recipe is that it only uses the egg yolks and adds slivered almonds for a nutty flavor.

Get the Rompope recipe at Isabel Eats.

This recipe combines two wintertime favorites: cozy hot chocolate and spiced eggnog. It doesn't have any alcohol so it's actually great for the whole family!

Get the Eggnog Hot Chocolate recipe at Sugar and Soul.

SHOP CHRISTMAS MUGS

Real pumpkin puree helps make this co*cktail become even creamier. Plus, the flavors pair perfectly with warm spices like cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, and cloves.

Get the Pumpkin Eggnog with Bourbon recipe at A Classic Twist.

Those who don't eat eggs don't have to miss out on the joyfulness of eggnog! This egg-free, dairy-free recipe is made with almond milk and cashews instead.

Get the Vegan Eggnog recipe at Jessica in the Kitchen.

This Cuban eggnog made with rum translates to “cream of life!” It's rich, sweet, and, of course, creamy thanks to the sweetened condensed milk.

Get the Crema de Vie recipe at A Sassy Spoon.

You only need three ingredients to make this easy holiday martini: Store-bought eggnog, vodka, and cinnamon simple syrup. For even more flavor, look for vanilla vodka or caramel vodka to add to the drink.

Get the Eggnog Martini recipe at Simple Joy.

This variation on eggnog is made with Irish cream liqueur. The best part? It's great for making ahead so your holiday entertaining has never been easier.

Get the Baileys Eggnog recipe at Burrata and Bubbles.

SHOP SAUCEPANS

This classic Puerto Rican co*cktail (pronounced ko-key-toe) is similar to eggnog, but not quite the same! It has flavors of coconut, cinnamon, and rum to make it stand out on its own.

Get the Coquito recipe at A Sassy Spoon.

This adorable pink drink is packed with peppermint flavor from the peppermint ice cream and crushed peppermint candies. A splash of sparkling ginger ale helps to tie it all together.

Get the Peppermint Eggnog Punch recipe at Love Bakes Good Cakes.

Gingerbread cookies just scream Christmastime so it's no wonder they make a festive addition to this holiday co*cktail. Here, you'll find all the warm, spiced, molasses flavor of gingerbread cookies, plus actual crushed cookies on top!

Get the Bourbon and Honey Gingerbread Eggnog recipe at Bourbon and Honey.

This recipe uses monkfruit sweetener to replace the sugar so it's keto-friendly for the holidays. There really is an eggnog for everyone!

Get the Keto Eggnog recipe at Food Faith Fitness.

Nobody knows if this recipe really came from George Washington but that's how the story goes! Give it a try for a little taste of American history this Christmas.

Get George Washington's Eggnog recipe at The View from Great Island.

SHOP ZESTERS